Discussion Papers and Discussion

The Discussion Room is divided into weeks. As you work with the essays in Ways of Reading, you'll write, post, and discuss six discussion papers. The weekly Assignment Instructions will describe in detail the discussion paper assignment for each week. Both the papers and the discussion are graded.

I won't participate in the discussion, but I'll read every paper and reply. At the end of each discussion period, I'll send you a message with a brief comment on your paper and discussion contribution, along with your discussion points for the week.

Choosing a Topic

Each discussion paper will be a response to an assignment in Ways of Reading, but Bartholmae and Petrosky's assignments are very open-ended. The easiest way to respond to their assignments is to notice interesting bits of the story and ask yourself questions about them—not factual questions, but questions of interpretation and meaning. Ask why something seems significant or what the implications of an image or bit of irony might be. Then explore possible answers to your question. You don't have to be certain of the answer, but you do have to be able to describe some evidence to support it. The ideal discussion paper is about something you don't understand very well but are willing to make some educated guesses about.

A good discussion paper topic springs from close observation, open-minded inquiry, insight, and clear reasoning.

A discussion paper should not be

  • A summary of the reading (the group has read it.)
  • A statement of the obvious
  • A research report
  • A collection of unrelated questions or observations
  • An ethnocentric criticism of the people about whom you're reading

Writing the Paper

Once you've found an interesting topic, write a paper that explores your ideas about it.

A good paper focuses clearly on a central question, observation, or idea, supports its points with specific detail, cites its source, and is written clearly and correctly spelled. There are no length requirements, but a good, narrow idea usually takes a page or two (300-500 words or so) to develop.

A discussion paper is not a polished essay. Keep it simple. It needs only three components:

  • A worthwhile main point about the possible significance or implications of your observation
  • An explanation of the reasoning that lies behind your point
  • Specific detail from the photographs and articles that illustrates your point and supports your reasoning

Advice

  • Paragraph your paper.
  • Don't begin by saying "In this paper I will show...." It sounds silly. No real writer ever begins that way. Instead, state your main point simply and briefly.
  • Don't worry about writing a good essay introduction. Just state your main point. The purpose and readers of a discussion paper are different from the purpose and readers of an essay in the same way the purpose and audience of an in-person discussion are different from those of a lecture. Talk to your readers, not at them.
  • Don't begin with a question; if your thinking started with a question, your main point should be a one-sentence "short answer" to the question. If I respond to your paper by asking what question you're answering, you'll know you haven't succeeded in making your main point clear.
  • Somewhere in the first paragraph, identify the photograph or article you're writing about and the bit you're focusing on by giving the page number(s) in parentheses.
  • The first time you mention an author use his or her full name. After that, use just the last name.
  • When you use detail from an article to help explain your reasoning, put it in your own words, but make sure your listeners know where it came from. Use the author's name in your sentence and give the page number where you found the detail. Enclose the page number in parentheses (...).
  • Don't quote whole sentences unless there's a very good reason to do so.
  • Use the present tense when you give detail from a photograph or article.
  • Don't end by saying "In conclusion. . . ." Real writers don't do that either. If you can't think of a graceful way to end, just stop. Unlike an essay, a discussion paper doesn't have to have a graceful conclusion.

Write your paper in MS Word (or another word-processing program), save it to disk, and copy (control C) and paste (control V) it into the Discussion. Be sure to include your name in the subject line (Example: Susie's Discussion Week 1 Paper).

Don't double space, and don't center your title or use special fonts, tabs, tables, bolding, or underlining. VISTA won't show any of this formatting unless you know how to use html. DO hit return twice after your title and between each paragraph.

If you want to format your paper, feel free to use VISTA's Create HTML commands. Check the Create HTML box and paste your paper into the window. You have to do the bolding and centering AFTER you paste your document into the discussion. If you use this function of VISTA, don't double space between paragraphs. VISTA will quadruple space if you do this.

Grading

I'll use three criteria to evaluate your papers. A strong paper will

  • State a clear, worthwhile interpretive main point within the first two or three lines and remain focused on it all the way through
  • Support the point with a clear line of reasoning and specific and accurate detail (citing line or page numbers)
  • Be sensibly paragraphed, clearly written, reasonably well punctuated, and carefully spell-checked. I'll point out major punctuation and grammar mistakes, but I won't grade you down for them unless they interfere with your readers' understanding of your ideas.

If English is not your native language, do the best editing you can in a reasonable amount of time. Readers have to be able to understand the meaning of each sentence, but don't worry if your grammar isn't perfect.

Discussing the Paper

You must participate in the discussion each week.

I'll divide the class into two discussion groups, each with its own space in the discussion. You'll post your paper in your own group's space and comment on your own group's papers. You're welcome to read and comment on the other group's papers, as well, but your comments in the other group won't count toward your total.

The purpose of the discussion as a whole is to help all of you generate ideas for the next essay. Therefore, the purpose of your comments is to explore the writer's ideas, not to critique or edit the paper. What does it mean to "explore ideas"? As you read the paper, note what you agree with, what delights you, what puzzles you, and why. Do you see other implications of the writer's ideas? Connections to other reading? Additional evidence that supports the ideas? Evidence that works against them?

Share your responses in a brief comment on the paper. Read other people's comments and respond to them. A good discussion consists of several people building on each other's ideas. A chain of responses to a single paper is called a "discussion thread."

Read all of the papers. Then comment in at least three other discussion threads in your group in addition to the one generated by your own paper. Be considerate. If you see a thread that has received very little attention, add a comment to it. People feel bad when others ignore their papers.

You must comment in at least three discussion threads in your group other than your own. The discussion period begins on the day the papers are posted in the discussion, usually a Tuesday. It usually ends on Friday of the same week. A good strategy is to make your first three comments on the day papers are posted. Then check in on at least one more day to read the rest of the papers and the new comments. Reading all of the papers and comments posted in your group will help you avoid stating the obvious in your next paper or essay.

Be careful about your tone of voice. In a written discussion a slightly critical comment can seem like a crushing condemnation because readers can't see the facial expressions and body language that tell them how serious you are. On the other hand, it's not a good idea to write "smiley-face" comments all the time. Those kinds of comments don't add anything substantial to the discussion. If you question or disagree with something someone has said, you need to say so—tactfully.

One way to express disagreement tactfully is to use question form: "Do you think we should consider ...?" Another way is to use tentative language: "But I wonder if we couldn't look at it from another angle..." These kinds of comments invite others to join the discussion and give their ideas. Remember—our purpose is to generate ideas, not to win verbal battles.

If another student hurts your feelings, explain briefly, calmly, politely, and publicly what it was that offended you. Then let the matter drop. I never reprimand people in the discussion, but if someone continues to offend after one of you has objected, I'll communicate with that person privately. If the behavior doesn't stop, I'll lower that student's discussion grade. If it continues after that, I’ll report the student’s name to the Dean of Students.

Make sure your readers know who and what you're replying to. When you write your reply, you'll be able to see the original, but when your readers read the reply, they'll see only the reply. Here are two ways to take care of the problem.

  • If you're responding to a few sentences, copy and paste those sentences into your reply and mention the name of the writer.
  • If you're responding to a larger chunk of the paper, summarize what you're responding to and mention the name of the writer.
  • If you're responding to someone else's comment, mention his or her name at the beginning of your reply.

If you follow this advice, your readers will not get confused about whether you're responding to the original paper or to a comment, and they'll always know what you're responding to.

You may also make "extra" posts if you wish. These are comments or questions that are not replies to other people's papers or comments. I take these into consideration when I look at the substance of your discussion.

Grading

To receive substantial points for the discussion, you must make substantial comments in at least three discussion threads other than your own, as well as responding to comments on your own paper. You‘re welcome to comment on papers in the other group, but only the comments in your own group will count toward your points.

A "substantial" comment

  • Is relevant to the current week's assignment
  • Builds on other people's ideas
  • Contributes to the group’s understanding of the topic
  • Encourages further responses

So how many comments does this add up to? Three, at minimum. If you post fewer than three, you'll lose significant points.

However, three comments will not earn you top discussion points, even if all three are substantial. If you make only three comments, you aren't contributing to the give and take of discussion. It's also hard to be sure all three are substantial, especially if you haven't read the rest of the discussion. The more comments you make, the more likely it is that at least three of them will meet the criteria for substance. Some people come up with their best ideas at the end of a long discussion.

Beyond this minimum, I don't grade by counting comments. I look at your overall contribution to the give and take of the discussion. Comments that pose useful questions, express appreciation of someone's contribution, or invite other students to respond are valuable in helping to keep the discussion going, even if they are not "substantial."

You'll see your discussion points at the end of the feedback message I send you. You'll also see them if you click on the tiny My Grades icon (the one with an A on it) on the toolbar to your left.